You should invest in a high-quality communication device because you’ll need it to communicate effectively in an emergency. For example, a headset allows you to hear what others say without listening to them talk over each other—this overview of the MSA Sordin Supreme Pro X vs. Safariland Liberator tactical communications headset.
Safariland Liberator vs. MSA Sordin Tactical Earmuffs
|Safariland Impulse Range Kit - Combine Foam Impulse Ear Protection with Compact Earmuffs for Two Layers (in & Over Ear) Hearing Protection + HD Flex Eyewear Safety Shooting Glasses||Check Prices|
|Safariland Pro Impulse In-Ear Hearing Protection | Tactically Filter Shooting Noises Without Blocking Ambient Sounds | Innovative Noise Filter Technology | Choose 1-Pair or 2-Pair Option||Check Prices|
|Sordin Supreme PRO X - Active Hearing Protection Safety Ear Muffs with Gel Seals - Black Canvas Headband and Cups||Check Prices|
|Sordin Supreme Pro X - Active Safety Ear Muffs with LED Light - Hearing Protection with Gel Seals - Camo Headband and Cups||Check Prices|
Before we make recommendations for headsets, let’s get you educated first. We need to know what you’re looking for before recommending the right headset for your needs.
The Liberator HP provides enhanced hearing protection in all environments, such as protection from impulse/gunfire noise and high decibel constant background audio. In contrast, advanced sound localization provides maximum situational awareness and sound detection.
Both headsets have versions that can attach to ballistic helmets, provide active noise cancellation against impulse noise, and feature sound dB noise reduction for gunfire.
Electronic headphones often come in the form of earphones due to their naturally superior sound-blocking ability, although sound-blocking headphones appear occasionally. Electronic shooting headphones add modern technology to the proven solutions of the past. The first time you pull the trigger without proper hearing protection, you will learn to appreciate a little distance hearing protection. Quality hearing protection will give you an NRR of at least 23 decibels, but some go well over 30 decibels.
MSA Sordin Supreme Pro X
- comms headset
- slim profile
- audio clarity
- vocal clarity
MSA Sordins are now better than ever before. They’re back in a big way! Their new design includes improved audio circuitry, stock Gel Cups, and a slightly improved battery compartment. These are the standard issue earplugs for most Marines at my base. Read the MSA Sordin Supreme Review here.
The Sordin Supreme Pro XL are the best headphones for gaming because they provide excellent sound quality, comfort, durability, and flexibility. They also come with an adjustable headband that doesn’t slip off your head while wearing a helmet.
According to the European single number rating system, the Sordin noise reduction rating is 25dB. But it’s 18db according to the American noise reduction rate system. The European system uses a higher standard (25 dB), while the American system uses a lower standard (18 dB). So since we’re using the American system, the Sordin noise reduction ratings are too low.
I’ve had a Sordins set for the last few years, great sets, and they’ve been my favorites for electronic ears when I hit the range. With both Sordin and DEHP, I compared the sound quality of each set side by side. I usually preferred the fit and comfort of the Peltors, but the Sordin has a much better sound quality.
The old-style MSA Sordin supreme basic headset had a battery compartment that required removing one of the ear cups before installing the AAA battery. This made it challenging to use helmets with low-cut necks.
However, Sordins work best with sloped stocks; rounded stocks will get in the way. It’s incredibly comfortable to wear on the range, and you can shoot for hours without ever feeling like you’re wearing anything. However, despite their superiority, their high price often puts off recreational shooters, and operators usually prefer their tried and true Peltor, Pro Ears or Sordin.
MSA Sordin Supreme Pro X with LED
The left ear cup has a small white LED light in the pivot post, which lights up when you hold the volume-up and volume buttons. These headphones are great for people who want to listen to music or watch movies without disturbing others around them. Left earcups feature a 3.5mm jack, connecting them to a push-to-talk headset. You can also connect these headphones to other devices with a headphone jack. The new style battery compartment is much easier to use. Headset options are limited to either headbands or neckbands. Modifying the headset to fit a high-cut helmet’s rails is possible but requires extensive modification.
White LEDs are a pain in the ass. Red LEDs are better than white ones. Battery compartments are hard to open, and batteries should fall out when removing them.
Another positive is its environmental resistance, although it is no better than Sordin Supreme Pro-X or ComTac III in terms of water and dust resistance. I assume that the environmental resistance of the headphones is not lower than that of the Sordin Supreme Pro-X and Peltor ComTac III. In that version, it was stated that the headphones had survivability when submerged to 15 feet but did not specify the dive time. I guess that the environmental resistance of the headphones was at least on par with the Sordin Supreme Pro-X and Peltor ComTac III. Safariland explains this by saying that their headphones do not have the clipping effect that other headphones do.
Safariland Liberator HP 2.0
- helmet rail mount
- Ops-Core AMP
- M-216™ Rail systems
- CR123A batteries
- separate battery tray
The Safariland TCI Liberator HP provides improved hearing protection in all environments, including pulsating/shooting noise and constant high decibel background sound. So, on the set of Steel Challenge, my wife couldn’t hear the shots with her Peltor, but she felt great with Sordin. I am MSA Sordins on steroids, in every sense of the word. I use active noise-canceling headphones to hear people talking and still get protection from harmful gunshot noise.
Best for the competition shooter also featuring Field Communications with an excellent noise reduction level.
They are designed to improve communication and situational awareness and protect your hearing before adding electronic magic to the equation. Designed, engineered, and built-in California, USA, the Safariland Liberator HP Earmuffs (starting at $299.99) reduce noise levels by up to 33dB.
One of the nice things about them is that when shipped back to Safariland, you can upgrade them to Liberator II or III headphones for those who need connectivity, which is nice. Replaceable gel ear cushions provide long-lasting comfort and a secure fit when wearing 3.5mm goggles and port tubes while listening to the radio, smartphones, and other devices. They include all the basic features you would expect from electronic hearing protection, although their NRR rating often reaches 25 decibels or lower.
They can still opt for Safariland Liberator headphones if they need connectivity, but DEHP-type headphones are left out. Instead, we received a DEHP pair of BTH (behind the ear) models. These headphones feature sound-activated compression with a 0.02 second response time to protect your hearing. These headphones are perfect for basic hearing protection, but when you need to get a proper weld, a low-profile pair of headphones is the only way to go.
It can be worn on a headband, over a helmet, or neckband. It includes gel ear pads that provide excellent comfort. The Liberator is a perfect choice for those who want to mount lights on their helmets. You can use it with either 2 AA batteries or 1 CR123 battery. It’s flexible enough to be attached to any helmet. The battery door is removable and water-resistant.
I’m not sure if the Liberator HP is the most comfortable pair of active hearing protection. But I know it works great! These are some of the best noise-canceling earphones out there. So you can hear everything around you without worrying about your surroundings. They’re also very comfortable. This product is made in the USA. It comes with an adjustable mount.
It has a dual power system. It is compatible with AAAs. It has a noise reduction rating of 26dB. It is available in four colors. It has a slim design. It is expensive. It does not come with any accessories.
It won’t be wrong to say that this headset captures more detail and sound than natural hearing. Liberator HP systems compress and reduce harmful sounds safely within the headset without muting other ambient or audio sounds. A front microphone picks up the sound on each of the two cups, well protected by a rubber casing. There are several solutions for this, and I think I’m right in my assumption that headphones are the most popular way.
Safariland now has the new Liberator HP headphones, which you can read below. Liberator HP headphones are the next generation of electronic hearing protection. Safariland Liberator HP – Hearing-only version (no connection) of the Liberator IV and V headphones. The Liberator HP is the base headset for the Liberator IV and V communication headsets and converts to a single or dual communication headset.
Safariland TCI Liberator V
- great for leisure shooters & range shooter
- integrated communications
- mode dependent
- clear sound profile
The only reason the Safariland TCI (Tactical Command Industries) Liberator V didn’t win best overall is that most people will not use all of the features. At almost $900 retail, that’s a lot to ask for a person who needs powered hearing protectors for shooting at the range… however, the Safariland TCI Liberator V isn’t only one of the best headsets on the market, but its one that I’ve had a lot of semi-professional experience with, given that the modified Liberator V comes with my target handoff system kit that I use as a forward observer for the marine reserves. In addition, the liberator V offers all the flexibility of a liberator HP, now fully realized in an audio communication headset that’ll handle just about anything you put at it.
Dual Comm Push To Talk (DCTP) is a military standard for voice communications developed by the U.S. Department of Defense. DCTP allows users to talk to other users over a radio frequency without being overheard by others listening nearby. The device consists of an earpiece, a microphone, and a push-to-talk button. A user presses the push-to-talk switch to speak.
The Liberator V sounds great and offers excellent noise cancellation. The Liberator V is also compatible with other headsets, allowing you to simultaneously use two or more headsets. This product is made in the USA. It was designed to be used outdoors. It uses two AAA batteries or one CR123 battery. It comes in four colors (Flat Dark Earth, OD Green, and Black). It has outstanding sound quality. It is flexible and durable. It is hardwired and downloaded. It is available only from Safariland. It has proprietary connections. It is expensive.
As we all know, most firearms produce an explosion that can damage our hearing if we don’t protect our ears. Unlike all standard electronic hearing protection headphones, these headphones cannot interact with radios, cell phones, or similar devices. As far as I know, this is the first case of electronic hearing protection along with the ANC function.
Safariland Liberator II Vs MSA Sordin Earmuffs
The muffs are similar to the Sordin, but Safariland has improved it. For example, here are some of the best shooting earmuffs. In addition, Safariland now has the new Liberator HP headphones, which you can read about above.
When connecting Sordin/MSA (TM) type headphones, use SARA adapters (sold separately). The MARK 2.0 kit will work with 3M Peltor(TM) headphones right out of the box. If there is further interest in another round of MSA Sordin Group purchasing for Pistol-Forum and you still agree with Tom_Jones, I’d be happy to ask SRS if they’re interested in quoting members here.
Any help in deciding which of the above headsets to purchase? I had a Sordin but sent it back because it didn’t provide what I thought was enough hearing protection. But that was over six years ago, and it has probably since changed. I’m happy with my 3M Peltor standard muffs but need an electronic type to hear Bullseye range commands. Performance is vastly more important to me than price.
Not sure if anything has changed since TCI became part of Safariland, but mostly MSA Sordin equipment with TCI electronics. I usually preferred the fit and comfort of the Peltors, but the Sordin has a much better sound quality.
They are designed to improve communication and situational awareness and protect your hearing before adding electronic magic to the equation. In addition, these headphones feature sound-activated compression with a 0.02 second response time to protect your hearing.
The downside to all headphones is how hot they get after being worn for a long time, so I usually wear custom-made ear tips. The biggest plus in my experience are the gel ear pads – they fit MUCH better on the glass and in general.